What’s happened to the Knicks? How could they been up 3-0 and then lose the next two? Can they even close out the Celtics in this series? And, more importanly, could we be witnessing the 2004 “Boston Red Sox-like Celtics” vieing to become the first NBA team in history to come from a 3-0 deficit to win a playoff series? Will history repeat itself?
This year’s Celtics are trying to repeat what the 2004 Red Sox did; coming back to win a series after being down 3-0. Photo: Ezra Shaw/Getty Images
Think about this stat: Just 11% of all NBA teams who were down 3-0 even make it to a game 6! This is what the Celtics have already accomplished and all we want to do is break down some of the reasons why and how we have gotten to this point.
For openers, we were at Game 1 at the Garden and can tell you that the Knicks played with a bit of a swagger, especially in the second half. That confidence extended into games 2 and 3 as the Celtics never scored 80 or more points in any of those games.
And then, with a comfortable lead near the last half of the 4th quarter of game 3, J.R. Smith got suckered into losing his cool after jawing with Jason Terry for most of the game. He elbowed the veteran, got ejected, and received a one game suspension from David Stern. The swagger left the court along with J.R. Smith and hasn’t returned in spite of the Knicks amazing comeback from being down 20 in game 4 to force the Celtics into OT.
#8 J.R. Smith shortly after elbowing #4 Jason Terry during game 3 on April 26th, 2013. Photo: Gettyimages
That act of pure stupidity by Smith, with his team up by double-digits at the time, was reminiscent of what took place with the Knicks in another heated rivalry back in 1997. The Knicks were up 3-1 in that series with the hated Miami Heat when, in game 5 P.J. Brown took offense over Charlie Ward’s attempt to gain position for a rebound. Brown flipped Ward over his head and body-slammed him, and a melee ensued.
The Heat’s P.J. Brown after slamming Knick Charlie Ward to the floor during the 1997 playoffs.
Patrick Ewing, Larry Johnson, Alan Houston and John Starks left the Knicks bench and when the smoked settled, Ewing, Houston and Ward were suspended for game 6 and Johnson and Starks for game 7. The Heat went on to win games 5, 6, and 7. That series, as this current one with the Celtics, was viewed as unwinnable at the time these actions took place.
Did Pat Riley tell P.J. Brown to instigate a brawl in the hopes of having the Knicks players lose their cool and face probable suspensions? Was Jason Terry ‘urged’ to incite a loose cannon like J.R. Smith? You be the judge.
This much is for certain. The Knicks wearing black at last night’s game 5 vs the Celtics, as if they were dressing for Boston’s funeral, did incite and infuriate coach Mike Woodson as well as a lot of Knick and basketball fans alike. The Knicks should stop the nonsense, put their collective noses to the grindstone, and do their best to try and win this series.
They have no reason to act so cocky. They ain’t won nuthin’ yet so maybe they should just settle down and play the same kind of ball they did in their first three games. And for those who think that the Knicks might have lost the last two because Chris Copeland didn’t play or Steve Novak didn’t play enough, give that a rest as well.
Chris Copeland has played a combined 24 minutes in this series shooting 0-5 with 1 rebound. Steve Novak has only been on the court for 31 minutes; 4-6 shooting for 10 points. (He also came out of last night’s game because of back spasms).
No, the Knicks need to remember what got them to 3-0 at the beginning of these playoffs in the first place; hard nosed defense, distribution of the basketball, and that ‘swagger’. All of which was lost to some extent with Smith’s suspension.
If you’re a Knicks fan, all you can hope for is that this series will not be the second coming of the 2004 Red Sox vs Yankees World Series, and that the team will not fall into any ‘traps’ during the remaining game(s); verbal or physical… otherwise history will just might repeat itself…
The Knicks need to avoid scenes like this in their remaining game(s). Photo: Gettyimages
FANTASY FURNACE 
The Knicks aren’t really known as a tough, hard-nosed team so they shouldn’t try to be. If they continue to try an mix it up and fight, then they are just playing into the Celtics hands. The Knicks can still win it, but they can’t beat the Celtics at their own game.
LikeLike
Strange isn`t it , here we are , now discussing the Knicks and you were somewhat critical when I suggested that Knicks weren`t mentally tough . Now the proof is here for all to see . Ironic or not , , this team remains mentally soft .
LikeLike
What they did last night wasn’t a sign of being soft Al. It was just plain stupid!
LikeLike
You know what was also stupid , was the insensitivity shown by the Knicks` players dressed in black in some sort of idiotic show of strength , said to have been thought up by butthead , K Mart , for the players to dress in black, to show their unison and allegedly done to show the Celtics that they were ready to close out the series . What was it that the boneheads on the roster failed to understand in the aftermath of the Boston Marathon tragedy ? Anal retentive idiots much like their totally obnoxious fans .
Tophatal …………
LikeLike
I couldn’t have said it any better Maurice! They seem to have a propensity towards finding trouble and getting way too pompous. That bit with them wearing black last night just gives the Celtics something else to slap on their locker room doors…
Thanks for checking in!
LikeLike
The Smith elbow reminds me of when John Starks ran down court and head butted Reggie Miller… I think the Knicks will close out the Celtics. This was one final roar before the lion went to sleep
LikeLike
Hope you’re right! And I remember that head butt. The Knicks fall prey to these trash-talkers all the time…
LikeLike
law of attraction what else can it be? lol The knicks a better than the C’s and Melo who has had a bad series will relax and let the game come to him and JR Smith will be …JR Smith and the Knicks will escape with a win.
LikeLike
For all the talk about how the western conference was THE conference…. I kinda like what the East has going on. The Knicks have a shot (literally), the Bulls are like Rocky Balboa, the Nets are from Brooklyn (which is never a bad thing), the Pacers are the last non-star team standing now that the Nuggets were sent home…..and the Heat have already been crowned, even though they’re still 12 wins shy of the finish line. I’m hoping for a Knicks vs Heat conference finals.
LikeLike
Would LOVE a Heat vs Knicks finals! I know the regular season doesn’t count for much but we did beat the Heat three times so one would think that we wouldn’t be intimidated by them. Also, have you seen the defense the Knicks CAN play when they want to?
First however, we’ll need to beat Indiana who has had the Knicks’ number this season..
LikeLike
If David Stern could work the NBA finals to be Knicks vs Heat, you KNOW he would be on it.
LikeLike
In a heartbeat!
LikeLike