Mike D’Antoni’s reign as N.Y. Knick coach has ended. Did he resign under his own accord or was he ‘squeezed’ by James Dolan and his cronies? We won’t know for sure and it doesn’t really matter.
Personally, the Knicks were turning into an embarassment; unruly crowds, the most turnovers in the league, players sulking on the bench, and shots on the basket being made randomly & without any plan or foresight. The Knicks had, for the most part, turned into a team of swing players with no direction and no teamwork.
The winning run led by Linsanity which had proven to be so sucessful through some ten games, did three things: It prolonged the inevitable resigning/firing of D’Antoni; it exposed Jeremy Lin once teams started watching more films and began preparing and double teaming the 23 year old which flustered him and basically took a major part of his game away; and once Carmelo returned from his groin and wrist injuries, it showed D’Antoni and the fans that Lin & Melo could not co-exist in D’Antoni’s run and gun style of offense mainly because Melo is what’s known as a ‘ballstopper’.
It is felt throughout the Knicks fan base as well as the media, that Carmelo, the ‘Incredible Sulk’, had the biggest influence in D’Antoni’s leaving. The constant pouting, his body langauge on the bench, towels covering his face ala Stephen Marbury, not getting involved in team huddles, an insurmountable amount of ill-advised shots, and displaying absolutely no signs of any defense, were all part of it.
Of course Melo will take no blame for the fact that he has also been shooting a career low 40% from the field during all this. Was that D’Antoni’s fault too?(Steve Novak shoots a higher percentage 47+, from beyond the arc!)
If history has shown us anything in the wide world of sports, it’s that a team’s highest paid player will not usually be traded or released before a head coach. Carmelo’s forcing Dolan & G.M. Glen Grunwald’s hand by his actions and by ‘claiming’ that he wanted to be traded, just exaserbated an already tenuous situation. The same thing happened with Magic Johnson and coach Paul Westhead, Michael Jordan and coach Doug Colins, and Jason Kidd and coach Byron Scott, just to name a few. Clearly there already have been many precedents set before Melo’s, where a star player was influential in getting a coach fired.
So Melo succeeded in accomplishing the end of D’Antoni’s run as the Knicks head-coach. Okay, now what? Under the assumption that Mike Woodson will be the coach for the Knicks’ 23 remaining games, who should take over the helm next season?
If he is to be given the benefit of the doubt, let’s start off with Woodson, who I personally like as a coach. He did an admirable job in Atlanta but just couldn’t get them to a championship. If anyone out there feels sorry for D’Antoni and his three year losing record in N.Y., how about Woodson? Here’s a coach, who in his last season with the Hawks went 53-29 and got fired! When is the last time a Knick team won 53 games? When Jimmy Carter was president?
If Woodson, by some miracle, could take this Knick team to the 2nd round of the playoffs, win or lose, he would almost assuredly be a shoe-in to return next year. If however the team continues to flounder in mediocroty for the remainder of the season, there are three other coaches to consider:
Former Jazz coach Jerry Sloan, it has been reported, inquired about the Knicks coaching job even before D’Antoni’s ‘resignation’. Although it would be a huge plus for N.Y., I have my doubts that he would entertain being in the N.Y. limelight and all that comes with it. Utah is just not the big apple…
Blazers coach Nate McMillan? He was being considered before D’Antoni even came to the Knicks three years ago by Isiah Thomas and Knicks owner James Dolan. That would be a long shot as he was recentlty given a contract extension but his job has been in question since the turmoil has begun to infiltrate Portland’s locker room.
The top choice for next season would be Phil Jackson. He’s always wanted to come to New York to coach his old team. He’s won with them here as a player, he’s won in Chicago, and he’s won in L.A. If there is one specialty that Jackson posesses, besides being a winner, it’s his ability to work with high profile players because they are usually the ones with high profile egos. And the Knicks have no shortage of players with high profile egos… If anyone can get Melo to perform it would be Jackson.
On the down side, Phil is 66 years old and more importantly has had several health concerns over the past few years. But if he’s up to the challenge, I can’t think of another coach that would have the full support of the team as well as the fan base plus the opportunity to come full cycle; from the first team he played with to the last team he’ll coach. Can Philsanity be far away?
Part of the problem of being a die-hard Knicks fan is the frequency with which folks look for some magic bullet to make us a championship contender. Last I checked we’ve had Pat Riley, Don Nelson and the just departed D’Antoni here on 33rd and Broadway in the past 21 years. But I do know this. Gulf + Western and Dolan have owned this team for most of the past 40 years. Maybe, just maybe, the Knicks need an ownership fully invested in hiring folks who are experts at building a team for the long haul, and not just trying to turn lead into gold, or (in Phil Jackson’s and Jerry Sloan’s cases) in finding the Fountain of Youth.
If either Van Gundy was available and willing to come to N.Y., I would take them in a heartbeat. I didn’t pick Jerry Sloan, although a successful coach in his own right. Don Nelson was another Mike D’Antoni in my estimation, and Pat Riley just couldn’t get another superstar along side of Patrick. Rick Pitino, same game as D’Antoni. Isiah Thomas? I’m not even going there….
Do you think that Jackson would not be a viable option for the Knicks? Who would you recommend?
Funny that you mention Nate McMillan, as he just got FIRED by the Blazers lol